167 Bay Shore, NY Houses Under $2,500
Sort: Best Match
Pet Friendly
$1,880+
Mid Island Apartments
Details
S
Studio
$1,880+
400+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,200+
665+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,165+
705+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease TermsOur lease terms are: 2 months, 3 months, 4 months, 5 months, 6 months, 7 months, 8 months, 9 months, 10 months, 11 months, 12 months, 13 months, 14 months, 15 months, 16 months, 17 months, 18 months, 19 months, 20 months, 21 months, 22 months, 23 months, 24 months. (Please note that lease terms may vary, are subject to change without notice, and are based on availability. Inquire with property staff for complete details).
NeighborhoodIslip
View All Details
5 Units Available
Pet Friendly
$2,390+
Fairfield North At Bay Shore Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,390
700+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,920
800+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,000
865+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12, 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodIslip
View All Details
Loading...
$2,155+
Fairfield On The Lake Apartments
Details
S
Studio
$2,155
416+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,250
497+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,375
757+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,415
849+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,875
1151+ sq. ft.
Lease Terms12, 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodIslip
View All Details
Pet Friendly
$2,295+
Fairfield Arms Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,295
580+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,295
580+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,850
890+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease TermsLease terms are variable. Please inquire with property staff.
NeighborhoodIslip
View All Details
3 Units Available
Pet Friendly
$2,285+
Fairfield Eastbrook Gardens Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,285
782+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,285
790+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,855
963+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,855
978+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodIslip
View All Details
4 Units Available
Pet Friendly
$2,380+
Fairfield South At Bay Shore Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,380
735+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,380
735+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,825
895+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,825
895+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodIslip
View All Details
$2,380+
Fairfield Tudor At Bay Shore Apartments
Details
2
2 Bed
$2,915
1
1 Bed
$2,380
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodIslip
View All Details
Pet Friendly
$2,255+
Fairfield Renaissance Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,255+
675+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12, 18, 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodIslip
View All Details
Pet Friendly
$2,315+
Fairfield Gardens At Bay Shore Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,315
650+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,850
800+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodIslip
View All Details
Loading...
Pet Friendly
$2,490+
Fairfield Saxon Arms Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,490
960+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,490
960+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,945
1078+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,945
1078+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodIslip
View All Details
Pet Friendly
$2,025+
Stone Water Gardens Apartments
Details
2
2 Bed
$2,275
1
1 Bed
$2,025
PetsCats
Lease Terms12-Month
NeighborhoodIslip
View All Details
1 Unit Available
$2,150
1bd 1ba 625 sq. ft.
$2,300
1bd 1ba
$2,300
1bd 1ba
$2,300
1bd 1ba
$2,300
1bd 1ba
Loading...
$2,300
1bd 1ba
$2,400
1bd 1ba
$1,700
1bd 1ba 250 sq. ft.
17 Views
$2,000
1bd 1ba 835 sq. ft.
28 Views
$1,585
1bd 1ba 800 sq. ft.
Details
Deposit$1,585
Date AvailableAvailable Now
Lease TermsMonth To Month
View All Details
$1,960+
The Belmont At Eastview Apartments
Details
S
Studio
$1,960
502+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
$2,125
506+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
$2,083
524+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,364
543+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
$2,128+
546+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
$2,138
548+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
$2,158+
569+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
$2,026
578+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
$2,026
578+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,451+
640+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,437+
645+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,628+
677+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,495+
702+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,522+
708+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
$2,554
765+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,761+
767+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
$2,273
778+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,955
778+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,506+
785+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,061
807+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
$2,781
823+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,625+
824+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,656+
834+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,665+
837+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,013+
840+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,221
851+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,763+
869+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,766
870+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,958+
873+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$4,007
904+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,014
906+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,040
914+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,091
930+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,524
934+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,974+
938+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,129
942+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,708
943+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,260
972+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,299
995+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,862
999+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$4,028
1043+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,148
1044+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,714+
1054+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$4,013
1068+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,887+
1078+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,591
1086+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$4,068
1098+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,910+
1108+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,136
1109+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,301+
1116+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,592+
1123+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,288
1126+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,995+
1138+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,493
1163+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,635
1204+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$4,251
1260+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,557
1323+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,680
1348+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$4,525
1377+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,697
1377+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,425
1400+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$4,673
1423+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,764
1428+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,828
1453+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,520
1580+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,342
1654+ sq. ft.
Lease TermsVariable
NeighborhoodIslip
View All Details
10+ Units Available
Special Offer
Pet Friendly
$2,195+
The Core Apartments
Details
S
Studio
$2,195+
441+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
$2,205+
441+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
$2,292+
517+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
$2,455+
548+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,805+
731+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,760+
739+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,010
744+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,035
762+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,008+
764+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,000+
781+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,015+
788+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,065+
794+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,104+
797+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,025+
797+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,929+
819+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,075+
819+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,200+
819+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,059+
827+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,080+
840+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,995+
843+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,930+
843+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,570+
905+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,760+
1045+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,760+
1157+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,970+
1170+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,809+
1197+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,130+
1202+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,970+
1230+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,235+
1231+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,045+
1267+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
$4,390+
1269+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
$4,375+
1282+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,095+
1315+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
$4,575+
1316+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,270+
1346+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
$4,555+
1377+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
$5,280
1446+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
$4,695+
1477+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease TermsVariable
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
10+ Units Available
Special Offer
Pet Friendly
$2,390+
Avalon Amityville Apartments
Details
S
Studio
$2,415
569+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
$2,390+
593+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
611+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
$2,490
629+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,865
703+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,855+
705+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,885+
719+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,890
748+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,835+
768+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
773+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,935
784+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,945
795+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,900
804+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,890
817+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,995
836+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,945
841+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,955
853+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
862+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
867+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
877+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
884+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
895+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
906+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
951+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,585
951+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
952+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
967+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,700
981+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
988+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$3,605
1025+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1034+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1038+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1044+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1047+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,500+
1062+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1067+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1068+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1083+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1088+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1089+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1093+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1136+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1145+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1149+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1153+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1159+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1165+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1169+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1170+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
1173+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,045
1243+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1266+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
1270+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1278+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1284+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1286+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1300+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1314+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,135
1331+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,890
1332+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,120
1336+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1336+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1348+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1352+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,145
1353+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1365+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1375+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1378+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
1404+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1412+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1473+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$4,120
1474+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
1477+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1511+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1519+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1564+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1569+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1588+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1596+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1634+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1759+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1788+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
$5,350
1859+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
1911+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
1969+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
2139+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
795-834+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,890+
748-931+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease TermsVariable
NeighborhoodBabylon
View All Details
10+ Units Available
Pet Friendly
$2,363+
Renaissance Hills Apartments
Details
S
Studio
$2,363
260+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,434
475+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,672
665+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,738
705+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,696
705+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,646
725+ sq. ft.
3
3 Bed
$3,817
1020+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12-Month
View All Details
3 Units Available
Pet Friendly
$2,335+
Fairfield Tudor At North Babylon Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,335+
600+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,775+
900+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,470+
1100+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,575+
1100+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12-Month, 18-Month, 24-Month
NeighborhoodBabylon
View All Details
Pet Friendly
$2,035+
Fairfield Sunrise Gardens Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,215
450+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
$2,045
482+ sq. ft.
S
Studio
$2,035
482+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,125
491+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,470
630+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,480
676+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,445
808+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,435
808+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,970
835+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,955
866+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,945
866+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,980
999+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodIslip
View All Details
10+ Units Available
Pet Friendly
$2,220+
Fairfield Greens At Holbrook Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,230
550+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,220
550+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,271
625+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,271
630+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,380
760+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,370
765+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,960
780+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,835
820+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,845
840+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,190
850+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,190
850+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,960
854+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,950
854+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,960
870+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,280
970+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12 & 24 month lease terms.
NeighborhoodIslip
View All Details
10+ Units Available
Pet Friendly
$2,475+
Fairfield Townhouses At Holtsville Apartments
Details
2
2 Bed
$2,925
2
2 Bed
$3,050
2
2 Bed
$3,250
2
2 Bed
$3,295
2
2 Bed
$3,075
1
1 Bed
$2,475
975+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,500
975+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,650
975+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,650
975+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,770
975+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,795
975+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$2,900
1100+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12-Month, 24-Month
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
Pet Friendly
$2,500+
Fairfield Charles Pond At Coram Apartments
Details
1
1 Bed
$2,500
723+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,550
760+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
891+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,810
907+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,745
913+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,770
924+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,995
1058+ sq. ft.
1
1 Bed
$2,995
1060+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,115
1102+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,190
1198+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
$3,295
1257+ sq. ft.
2
2 Bed
1399+ sq. ft.
PetsDogs/Cats
Lease Terms12-Month, 24-Month
NeighborhoodBrookhaven
View All Details
10+ Units Available
Number of Bedrooms
Bay Shore House Options
Bay Shore
Houses 3D and Video ToursBay Shore
Houses with Air ConditioningBay Shore
Houses with Disability AccessBay Shore
Houses with DishwasherBay Shore
Houses with ElevatorBay Shore
Houses with Fire PlaceFurnished Houses
in
Bay ShoreBay Shore
Houses with GarageBay Shore
Houses with Gated AccessBay Shore
Houses with Patio / BalconyBay Shore
Houses with Senior LivingBay Shore
Houses with Washer / Dryer ConnectionsBay Shore
Houses with Washer / Dryer In UnitPet Friendly Houses for Rent in Bay ShoreCheap Houses for Rent in Bay ShoreLuxury Houses for Rent in Bay ShoreRooms for Rent in Bay Shore
Nearby Cities
Ocean Beach, NYBay Shore, NYHuntington, NYWest Babylon, NYPort Jefferson Station, NYFarmingdale, NYFreeport, NYBellport, NYPatchogue, NYPoint Lookout, NYSayville, NYBabylon, NYOyster Bay, NYCentral Islip, NYCoram, NYMassapequa, NYCopiague, NYHuntington Station, NYWestbury, NYAmityville, NYMiddle Island, NYNorthport, NYDeer Park, NYLindenhurst, NYBethpage, NYBrentwood, NYEast Meadow, NYHempstead, NYIslip, NYLevittown, NYRonkonkoma, NYStony Brook, NYCentereach, NYEast Islip, NYHauppauge, NYHicksville, NYPlainview, NYSmithtown, NYSyosset, NYWest Islip, NYCommack, NYFarmingville, NYGlen Head, NYJericho, NYMerrick, NYNorth Babylon, NYBaldwin, NYBayport, NYEast Northport, NYGreenlawn, NYHolbrook, NYLake Grove, NYPort Jefferson, NYSeaford, NYSelden, NYWantagh, NYBellmore, NYBohemia, NYDix Hills, NYGarden City, NYIslip Terrace, NYMedford, NYMelville, NYNesconset, NYOakdale, NYRoosevelt, NYUniondale, NYWest Sayville, NYWyandanch, NY
Nearby Neighborhoods
Looking for more?
Other Properties in New York
78-34 69th Ave #2311 S Aurora St unit 311Seneca Pointe Senior Apartments31-32 12th St unit 2100 W Broadway #3C164 W 73rd St unit 5F54 Wadsworth Terrace unit 498 Wallace Rd619 Glenwood AveEast 54th Street39 Kings Point RdBrighton Colony Townhomes Apartments42 Alder St #12222 Jackson Ave unit 81422-46 47th St #23451 Giles Pl36 Cedar StThompson Park Apartments120 E 102nd St unit 1Genesee Pointe Apartments201 Pearl St88 Leonard Apartments2199 Cruger Ave unit D4201 E 36th St #2E800 2nd Ave #806200 E. 87th Apartments688 Central Ave10 Center Boulevard631 E 6th St unit 1BCanterbury Gardens Apartments
Rentals.com is part of the Rent. Network of Sites
© 2024 Rent Group Inc. All photos, videos, text and other content are the property of Rent Group Inc. RENTALS.COM and the RENTALS.COM Trade Dress are registered trademarks of Rent Group Inc. All rights reserved.
If you are using a screen reader, or are having trouble reading this website, please email accessibilityfeedback@rent.com.